Skip to main content

Identification of SNPs associated with variola virus virulence



Decades after the eradication of smallpox, its etiological agent, variola virus (VARV), remains a threat as a potential bioweapon. Outbreaks of smallpox around the time of the global eradication effort exhibited variable case fatality rates (CFRs), likely attributable in part to complex viral genetic determinants of smallpox virulence. We aimed to identify genome-wide single nucleotide polymorphisms associated with CFR. We evaluated unadjusted and outbreak geographic location-adjusted models of single SNPs and two- and three-way interactions between SNPs.


Using the data mining approach multifactor dimensionality reduction (MDR), we identified five VARV SNPs in models significantly associated with CFR. The top performing unadjusted model and adjusted models both revealed the same two-way gene-gene interaction. We discuss the biological plausibility of the influence of the SNPs identified these and other significant models on the strain-specific virulence of VARV.


We have identified genetic loci in the VARV genome that are statistically associated with VARV virulence as measured by CFR. While our ability to infer a causal relationship between the specific SNPs identified in our analysis and VARV virulence is limited, our results suggest that smallpox severity is in part associated with VARV strain variation and that VARV virulence may be determined by multiple genetic loci. This study represents the first application of MDR to the identification of pathogen gene-gene interactions for predicting infectious disease outbreak severity.

Peer Review reports


Smallpox, the only human infectious disease to have been eradicated, remains a threat as a potential agent of bioterrorism. Mortality rates during natural outbreaks of smallpox varied widely, a feature partially attributed to strain-specific virulence of the etiological agent, the orthopoxvirus variola virus (VARV) [1]. An understanding of the genetic determinants of virulence of VARV is critical for predicting the potential of different strains for causing severe epidemics.

We analyzed the genome-wide single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of a collection of 35 temporally, geographically and epidemiologically diverse VARV isolates housed at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s secure repository (previously described in [2]) for associations with VARV virulence. We investigated the only known metric of innate virulence of these isolates, their case fatality rates (CFRs), which range from <1-30% [2]. Previously, outbreaks of smallpox have been classified as ‘major’ when they exhibit greater than 10 percent CFRs. Because CFR can be considered a complex phenotype of VARV that is likely mediated by, among other factors, multiple viral genetic loci, we focused on identifying combinations of SNPs that may interact in their associations with CFR. We used the non-parametric data mining approach known as multifactor dimensionality reduction (MDR), described previously [3]. Briefly, MDR evaluates candidate models based on all possible combinations of a given number of SNPs and applies a naive Bayes classifier with cross-validation to estimate the testing accuracy of each candidate model. The statistical significance of the model that maximizes the testing accuracy is then assessed by permutation testing. MDR has been used extensively to detect epistatic interactions in genome-wide association studies of complex human diseases such as cancer, autism and cardiovascular disease. This study is novel in its application of MDR to pathogen genome data.

From the full-genome sequences of the 35 isolates we studied, we identified 1730 SNPs using kSNP with k=25 [4]. We built a list of candidate SNPs for MDR analysis by removing SNPs unlikely to have relevance to VARV virulence, including 979 synonymous SNPs and another 192 SNPs located in hypothetical proteins. Of the remaining 559 SNP loci, 126 were missing character states for one or more isolates. We eliminated from our analysis 92 SNPs that were missing data for more than one isolate. The remaining missing character states were imputed by replacing them with the most commonly observed character state for that SNP. 345 SNPs with allele frequencies of less than 10 percent (in fewer than 4 genomes) were also removed from the dataset, leaving 122 candidate SNPs. We grouped SNP loci that were perfectly collinear, that is, were in complete linkage disequilibrium in our sample of isolates. These loci are redundant and impossible to distinguish in our models. This left us with 21 individual SNPs or SNP groups as candidate attributes for our MDR models.

Our outcome of interest was CFR, coded as a binary variable where 0 represented CFRs ≤ 10 percent and 1 represented CFRs > 10 percent. Of the 35 isolates, 18 were associated with CFRs > 10 percent. Preliminary analyses revealed that CFR is significantly associated with geographic location, namely, whether the outbreak occurred on the African continent (Fisher’s exact test, p<0.001); therefore, in adjusted models we included a binary covariate where 0 represented strains isolated from non-African outbreaks and 1 represented strains isolated from African outbreaks. We fit one-way, two-way and three-way SNP-SNP interaction models using MDR. All models were fit using five-fold cross-validation and evaluated for significance using 1000 random permutations [5].

Previous work has shown that these isolates form two major phylogenetic clades, with the clade containing Asian and non-West African VARV variants, referred to as primary clade I in [6], exhibiting different biological properties than the clade containing West African and South American variants [6, 7]. Accordingly, we investigated the sensitivity of our modeling approach to phylogenetic differences by performing the same analysis on the set of isolates belonging to primary clade I. This model could not be adjusted for a geographic association between CFR and African origin because CFR and geographic origin are perfectly correlated among isolates in this clade.

Our models identified 5 individual SNPs and 2 groups of perfectly collinear SNPs that significantly predict smallpox CFR (Table 1). SNPs are hereafter referred to by their positions in the genome of the reference strain gi|94484460|gb|DQ441420.1| Variola virus strain Bangladesh 1974 (nur islam). These SNPs represent loci in 19 different VARV genes (Table 2). We used testing balanced accuracy, a measure of model accuracy that avoids inflating performance estimates due to unbalanced data to measure the performance of each model. The same two-way SNP-SNP interaction was identified in both the top-performing unadjusted and adjusted models (Table 1). The top-performing unadjusted model slightly outperformed the corresponding adjusted model; however, the difference in model testing balanced accuracy was small and both models were significant. When we restricted our analysis to only the isolates in primary clade I, we identified two models with equal testing balanced accuracy values, a two-way model and a three-way model. However, the two-way model performed better was more consistently selected in cross-validation. In all three analyses, the top-performing model revealed the same two-way effect of an interaction between SNP 127469 and one or more SNPs in group 1 on CFR.

Table 1 Summary of models evaluated by MDR for predicting smallpox outbreak CFRs using VARV SNPs
Table 2 SNPs identified in MDR analysis of associations between VARV genetic variation and smallpox outbreak CFRs

SNP 127469 was involved in all models with the exception of the one-way unadjusted models. This SNP falls within the gene encoding the cowpox A-type inclusion protein. In some orthopoxviruses, the A-type inclusion protein forms inclusion bodies in the cytoplasm of infected cells, into which mature virus particles are embedded. The presence of inclusion bodies probably enhances survival and dissemination in the environment [8, 9]. VARV, like other orthopoxviruses, has a conserved A-type inclusion protein gene; however, VARV-infected cells accumulate large quantities of the protein without forming typical inclusion bodies, which suggests that it may have some other function. The A-type inclusion protein has been shown in the prototypical orthopoxvirus vaccinia virus to be highly immunogenic, and variants of vaccinia with mutations in the A-type inclusion protein gene exhibit reduced immunogenicity [10].

The other variable in our top models, group 1, represents a group of 4 perfectly collinear SNPs that cannot be distinguished among the strains in our sample. SNP 28347 falls within a gene for a serine/threonine kinase that phosphorylates virion proteins involved in assembly. SNP 126854 falls within a second gene for the cowpox A-type inclusion protein. SNP 136573 is a polymorphism in the gene encoding A36R, a transmembrane phosphoprotein of the intracellular enveloped virion (IEV) form. The IEV is the precursor to the extracellular cell-associated enveloped virion, which requires this protein for producing the actin tails that push it away from the cell surface and allow it to disseminate to adjacent cells. Loss of A36R results in a small plaque phenotype in vitro and in reduced virulence in vivo[11]. SNP 151088 is a locus in the gene for the hemagglutinin protein. It is found in the extracellular enveloped virus form of VARV. In the vaccinia virus model, in which it is known as the A56 protein, it is able to bind two viral proteins, K2, a serine protease inhibitor, and VCP, the vaccinia virus complement control protein, to the surface of infected host cells. With A56, K2 reduces the amount of virus superinfecting an infected cell and prevents the fusion of infected cells, while the VCP complex inhibits complement activity. Deletion of this gene impacts vaccinia virus virulence [12].

Other models identified by our MDR analysis performed inferiorly to these; however, they allowed us to identify SNPs that were significantly associated with CFR. SNP 183083 was found in two relatively high-performing models, both the one-way and three-way unadjusted models. This SNP is in the gene for the CrmB secreted TNF-alpha-receptor-like protein. This is a TNF-alpha receptor expressed by poxviruses that blocks cytokine activity to interfere with the host immune function, thereby enhancing viral virulence [13]. Additional SNPs identified in our analysis are shown in Table 2 and include loci in genes that encode additional host defense modulators and proteins critical to the viral life cycle.

This study represents a novel application of MDR to studying pathogen genome-wide associations with infectious disease outbreak severity. Of the models we evaluated using MDR, the best-performing model predicted smallpox outbreak CFR with a two-way VARV gene-gene interaction. While we are limited in our ability to infer a causal relationship between the interacting SNPs identified in our analysis and smallpox outbreak severity, the genes implicated have potential biological plausibility as determinants of VARV virulence and may represent targets for future laboratory-based investigations. The results of this study reinforce existing evidence that smallpox outbreak severity may be in part a consequence of the VARV strain associated with the outbreak and suggests that VARV virulence is a complex trait influenced by multiple genetic loci.



Case fatality rate


Extracellular enveloped virus


Intracellular enveloped virion


Multifactor dimensionality reduction


Single nucleotide polymorphism


Variola virus.


  1. Shchelkunov SN, Totmenin AV, Loparev VN, Safronov PF, Gutorov VV, Chizhikov VE, Knight JC, Parsons JM, Massung RF, Esposito JJ: Alastrim smallpox variola minor virus genome DNA sequences. Virology. 2000, 266: 361-386. 10.1006/viro.1999.0086.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  2. Esposito JJ, Sammons SA, Frace AM, Osborne JD, Olsen-Rasmussen M, Zhang M, Govil D, Damon IK, Kline R, Laker M, Li Y, Smith GL, Meyer H, Leduc JW, Wohlhueter RM: Genome sequence diversity and clues to the evolution of variola (smallpox) virus. Science. 2006, 313: 807-812. 10.1126/science.1125134.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  3. Ritchie MD, Hahn LW, Roodi N, Bailey LR, Dupont WD, Parl FF, Moore JH: Multifactor-dimensionality reduction reveals high-order interactions among estrogen-metabolism genes in sporadic breast cancer. Am J Hum Genet. 2001, 69: 138-147. 10.1086/321276.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  4. Gardner SN, Slezak T: Scalable SNP analyses of 100+ bacterial or viral genomes. J Forensic Res. 2010, 01: 107-

    Article  Google Scholar 

  5. Greene CS, Himmelstein DS, Nelson HH, Kelsey KT, Williams SM, Andrew AS, Karagas MR, Moore JH: Enabling personal genomics with an explicit test of epistasis. Pac Symp Biocomput. 2010, 327-336.,

    Google Scholar 

  6. Li Y, Carroll DS, Gardner SN, Walsh MC, Vitalis Ea, Damon IK: On the origin of smallpox: correlating variola phylogenics with historical smallpox records. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007, 104: 15787-15792. 10.1073/pnas.0609268104.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  7. Dumbell KR, Huq F: The virology of variola minor. Correlation of laboratory tests with the geographic distribution and human virulence of variola isolates. American J Epidemiol. 1986, 123: 403-415.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  8. Ichihashi Y, Matsumoto S, Dales S: Biogenesis of poxviruses: Role of A-type inclusions and host cell membranes in virus dissemination. Virology. 1971, 46: 507-532. 10.1016/0042-6822(71)90056-0.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  9. Howard AR, Weisberg AS, Moss B: Congregation of orthopoxvirus virions in cytoplasmic A-type inclusions is mediated by interactions of a bridging protein (A26p) with a matrix protein (ATIp) and a virion membrane-associated protein (A27p). J Virol. 2010, 84: 7592-7602. 10.1128/JVI.00704-10.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  10. DeCarlos A, Paex E: Isolation and characterization of mutants of vaccinia virus with a modified 94-kDa inclusion protein. Virology. 1991, 185: 768-778. 10.1016/0042-6822(91)90548-P.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  11. Parkinson JE, Smith GL: Vaccinia virus gene A36R encodes a M(r) 43-50 K protein on the surface of extracellular enveloped virus. Virology. 1994, 204: 376-390. 10.1006/viro.1994.1542.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  12. Dehaven BC, Gupta K, Isaacs SN: The vaccinia virus A56 protein: a multifunctional transmembrane glycoprotein that anchors two secreted viral proteins. J Gen Virol. 2011, 92: 1971-1980. 10.1099/vir.0.030460-0.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  13. Alejo A, Ruiz-Argüello MB, Ho Y, Smith VP, Saraiva M, Alcami A: A chemokine-binding domain in the tumor necrosis factor receptor from variola (smallpox) virus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006, 103: 5995-6000. 10.1073/pnas.0510462103.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

Download references


This work was supported by NIH grant R01 AI059694 and was performed in part under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344. The authors are grateful to Peter Andrews for MDR software support and to Diane Gilbert-Diamond and Nadia Penrod for helpful discussions.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations


Corresponding author

Correspondence to Jason H Moore.

Additional information

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors’ contributions

AGH participated in the study design, performed the statistical analysis and drafted the manuscript. SNG performed SNP analysis and contributed to the interpretation of the data and the drafting of the manuscript. JHM conceived of the study, participated in the study design and statistical analyses and contributed to interpretation of the data and the drafting of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License ( ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Hoen, A.G., Gardner, S.N. & Moore, J.H. Identification of SNPs associated with variola virus virulence. BioData Mining 6, 3 (2013).

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: