Skip to main content

Table 5 Performance of models (G-mean)

From: Influenza, dengue and common cold detection using LSTM with fully connected neural network and keywords selection

 

Dataset

dengue + cold

flu+ dengue + cold

flu+ cold

SMS Spam Collection Dataset

Model Architecture / Filing missing

LSTM

LSTM with numerical

LSTM + FNN

LSTM

LSTM with numerical

-LSTM + FNN

LSTM

LSTM with numerical

LSTM + FNN

LSTM

original

 

0.692

0.800

0.771

0.458

0.586

0.543

0.528

0.532

0.565

0.854

MG

 

0.729

0.766

0.773

0.588

0.592

0.531

0.526

0.524

0.481

0.852

keywords selection (cut words: frequency < 2)

cubic interpolation

0.768

0.752

0.779

0.488

0.533

0.513

0.649

0.682

0.695

0.820

cut

0.758

0.798

0.808

0.402

0.594

0.601

0.530

0.532

0.565

0.849

mean

0.732

0.699

0.742

0.498

0.569

0.568

0.624

0.682

0.608

0.894

keywords selection (cut words: MI bottom 5%)

cubic interpolation

0.734

0.545

0.649

0.300

0.383

0.286

0.670

0.719

0.744

0.871

cut

0.690

0.569

0.697

0.522

0.546

0.460

0.317

0.397

0.574

0.860

mean

0.641

0.613

0.599

0.542

0.505

0.528

0.678

0.701

0.607

0.896

keywords selection (cut words: MI bottom 5% or frequency < 2)

cubic interpolation

0.715

0.628

0.599

0.372

0.392

0.439

0.667

0.687

0.757

0.851

cut

0.668

0.568

0.714

0.497

0.556

0.478

0.319

0.357

0.569

0.886

mean

0.714

0.599

0.605

0.488

0.555

0.560

0.676

0.675

0.609

0.900

keywords selection (cut words: frequency < 2) + MG

cubic interpolation

0.763

0.759

0.762

0.466

0.532

0.529

0.565

0.671

0.711

0.849

cut

0.725

0.723

0.818

0.482

0.576

0.528

0.526

0.526

0.483

0.845

mean

0.738

0.728

0.782

0.584

0.596

0.553

0.621

0.654

0.673

0.876

keywords selection (cut words: MI bottom 5%) + MG

cubic interpolation

0.698

0.606

0.620

0.222

0.000

0.282

0.661

0.728

0.754

0.864

cut

0.680

0.655

0.641

0.484

0.555

0.455

0.402

0.358

0.495

0.876

mean

0.697

0.621

0.590

0.490

0.501

0.477

0.656

0.642

0.766

0.894

keywords selection (cut words: MI bottom 5% or frequency < 2) + MG

cubic interpolation

0.703

0.604

0.581

0.293

0.000

0.405

0.677

0.722

0.716

0.845

cut

0.671

0.609

0.642

0.483

0.537

0.504

0.364

0.359

0.492

0.836

mean

0.697

0.621

0.590

0.478

0.563

0.529

0.678

0.647

0.666

0.884